Merge
| This Discussion is Closed | ||
| The result of this discussion is: Guenael is a highly developed character, we have more informtation on him than just that he is a figment of Gremmy's imagination | ||
|---|---|---|
| Please do not edit this discussion. | ||
Since Guenael is just a creation of Gremmy's ability, shouldn't we create a page for Gremmy as the "main" Sternritter, and merge Guenael into Gremmy's page, like James is merged under Mask De Masculine's page as a subordinate? After all, Guenael didn't make much of an impression or significant impact to have his own page, like some of the Sternritter members (Berenice Gabrielli and Jerome Guizbatt, for example) and considering that he isn't a real Sternritter nor an actual living person to begin with. Yatanogarasu (talk) 19:13, March 22, 2014 (UTC)
Hmm I'm not sure but you're proposal does sound reasonable, let's wait for a admin to respond before we push the agenda forward. Mr.Rig and Zig 19:25, March 22, 2014 (UTC)
Gremmy will likely get a page of his own when there is enough information to justify it, which will likely be the case after next weeks chapter. Guenael's page is well developed enough to justify its existence as a page of its own, it doesn't need to be merged with anything. James is listed on Mask's page because when that was done, there was very little info on him and that was a handy place to put it. While he got more development after that, there is nowhere near as much info as Guenael and I'm not sure James has enough to justify a page of his own like Guenael has. ~~Ууp <talk> 19:36, March 22, 2014 (UTC)
Nevermind this issue has already arisen on the talk page for Sternritter Members. 'Mohrpheus wrote': "Despite apparently being imaginary, Guenael was considerably more developed than James was compared to Mask. I agree that Gremmy should probably have his own page, but we are probably waiting until we have a little more information on him, which will more than likely come along next week." So there you go the answer is no. Mr.Rig and Zig 19:31, March 22, 2014 (UTC)
Race Status, Team, Sternritter Status
I think we need to review the status of Guenael regarding him being a Sternritter. On Talk:Sternritter#Guremi_and_Gunael Chiligrinder states correctly that Guenael never introduced himself as "Sternritter V - The Vanishing Point". If you want to take the other points made by Chiligrinder into account, as well as the fact that Guenael was removed from Sternritter List, I would propose the following:
Leave the Sternritter reference in the introduction of the article, but:
Race: Quincy Powers (like Zangetsu (Quincy Powers), of course he is just one aspect of Gremmy's powers, not their embodiment, but there is no other category.)
Team: none, or just Wandenreich
Partner: Gremmy Thoumeaux
I know that we might get new information on Guenael later on, in BOOK OF SOULS/special magazine etc., but I think these are our given information for now?Rafer.Alston (talk) 23:32, June 4, 2014 (UTC)
Hmm you're proposal does seem quite reasonable and well sourced but let's wait for an admin or lieutenant to respond okay? Mr.Rig and Zig 00:05, June 15, 2014 (UTC)
Relatives
So, should we add Gremmy to Guenael's relatives section? After all, Gremmy did create him and Mayuri is also stated to be Nemu's relative despite not being her biological father afaik. Timjer (talk) 17:04, February 24, 2020 (UTC)