Board Thread:Improvements and Issues/@comment-36620412-20191115231026/@comment-957629-20191117234038

You stated there was no note of reference, there is. Yes the link itself is dead but I know at the time it worked because I saw it myself.

Kubo using feminine pronouns for a character who presents themselves as female, only proves that he uses feminine pronouns for character that identifies as female.

Kubo has contradicted himself often enough (retcons and such are very common like Ukitakes eyes) but until he contradicts those notes, that's all we have to go by.

We cannot decide the source is wrong just because they have been wrong in the past. As stated above, that would be like attaching "Well Kubo gave Ukitake brown eyes originally and now they're green so we cannot reference anything the manga as true because Kubo may change his mind later" to every reference or article.

As it stands, the Trivia point just says there were notes attached to the release of Chapter 615 that confirmed Giselle was born male. Whether or not the notes are wrong, the point is corect because the notes did say that.

You can say "no need to be rude" but saying something is "incorrect" without proof it is incorrect is a fallacy in itself. That's like saying that Evolution is untrue because we were wrong when thought that the atom was the smallest unit of mass in the universe.

But even if Kubo did come out and say the notes were wrong, the trivia point still stands, the notes confirmed it, there is no conclusion on how true the notes are.