Board Thread:Improvements and Issues/@comment-36620412-20191115231026/@comment-36620412-20191117235758

Well, I was sincerely trying to bring this about in the most polite possible way and I was met with the most antagonistic responses possible.

Alright, I basically studied both of your posts and just read the same thing as you continue to avoid what I was saying. The examples you gave to "contradict" me were not the same as what I'm suggesting. the notes could say "hey! by the way, there's contradicting statements about Giselle's gender, such as Kubo only using female pronouns or the novels only referring to her as she." I'm not saying one or the other is a be all end all of what the truth is, but narrowing the story down to one point of view is kind of forcing your agenda, yeah?

I have as much proof of it being incorrect as you do of it being correct. You have a flimsy source at best, and if mine is no better, where do we stand.

Kubo contradicting himself is not a good reasoning for your argument, either. um... Then we should probably include all of those contradictions on the wiki, because if someone read an early chapter of bleach and saw something that didn't line up with your wiki because of a later contradiction, one might think your wiki isn't a reliable source, simply because you didn't include all of the information.

Way to cover all of your bases, though. ;-)

Again, Occam's Razor.

Also, I never accused the entire wiki of anything. I said that doing such a thing isn't something I would consider professional, "believe it or not."

Well, I've said my piece. and it seems there's no point in trying to have a civil conversation here. That got unnecessarily nasty way too quickly.

I had an assumption the reaction would be negative which is why I tried to be nice about it and instead of shoehorning my information into the article, I simply tried to share my information here as a suggestion.

Again, maybe Kubo will confirm it one day or another. Until the, we don't know. Like it or not, we might think that we know, but we really don't know.

I feel content that I shared my piece and don't feel the need to continue the conversation with people who won't properly look over my text. It's not a good use of time.

You can also feel free to have the last word, since that is obviously what you want.

au revoir, mon amour - ¯\_(ツ)_/¯