Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-3047317-20130425041002/@comment-3047317-20130519050315

Man, you are crude, rude, and completely hung up upon this.

One, I never said Haschwalth wasn't sympathetic. When did I ever say that? I'm talking only about YHWACH. And Royd copied Yhwach's powers, memories and personality almost perfectly, debatablely up until the point where he was swarmed by his fallen from 1000 years ago.

Two, he did indeed say 'you did well', I know that, but that is hardly true caring when Yamamoto said 'evil' after, sensing the evil callous intent behind his annihilation. You can congratulate an insect if it serves you super well before squashing it. Did he not do the same to the Ebern, congratulating him on becoming a 'pillar for peace', before killing him? Canon statement on Chapter 506, page 13: "You have not changed Juha Bach. But the wicked way you look down upon your own men...will also end here."

In other words, he looked down upon his Quincy men before he was defeated years ago. Canon statement from Yamamoto.

Two part 2, Ichigo and Uryuu are high war potentials, as confirmed by Bach and Kirge. He may care a little about his bloodline, but he already regained his sanity when he stripped away the power of half bloods, even those who relied on that power to live or survive.

Third, your patheticly immature eye doctor insult falls flat when YOU forget certain facts. Canon quote after Yamamoto kills 3 Vandenreich: 1 verified by no mask as not an arrancar. Chapter 506, Page 11-12. "Foolish people. Its their fault meddling in my fight." No remorse whatsoever.

Four, if you're basing your entire argument on a 'you did well' statement that, which not only was used on an arrancar, Ebern, as well before annihilation...make sure its a picture where he's actually showing some remorse. Otherwise, its just chopped up to normal YHWACH cruelty/sympathy.

Five, my statement is that all evidence shows he's not an arrancar, and assuming he's NOT generalizing is just as presumptious as saying he is. Even less so since his second-in-command did not speak up until Ebern was killed. Even if we pretended what Yamamoto said in Chap 506, Pg 13 didn't happen, we still don't know if Luders is a Quincy or some sort of human/quincy hybrid, like we are still guessing at from the sheer amount of Quincy's. (some suspect Fullbringers converted by Quincy powers, but who knows)

All we know is all evidence is to the contrary that Luders was an arrancar, as I have pointed out all the evidence. The fact he has both a German first name and last name makes it even cemented, while Ebern had a made-up japanese last name.

I'm not saying I'm outright right. I'm just saying it makes more sense to label him a quincy more then an arrancar due to evidence. We label all pure quincy's, part-quincy's, and potentially human-converted quincies as Quincies right?

Unless you have ANY verifiable evidence to the contrary, the rest of the evidence states he's either a quincy or a 'new' quincy, which we simply don't have enough info to disparage against....yet.