User blog comment:UraharaHitsugaya/Pick a Lieutenant/@comment-1669175-20100525005820

It really depends on the type of captain you are going to be...if you are a person to joke around, you pick someone like Hisagi or Kira that'll do all your work for you, but if you are planning to be that serious captain that doesn't delegate much work, someone like Matsumoto or Ikkaku.

Personally, I would pick Hisagi...He just has a demeanor that I can relate to, and if I was ever not feeling like working that day, he'd obviously pick up the slack. Realistically, picking any of the 2-3 Lts that are already performing Captains duties (Kira, Hisagi) wouldn't be a bad decision to make.