User blog comment:WhiteArmor/Ichigo-Teichou?/@comment-1393830-20100410004842

First off he will not be a captain since he is not dead. However if we are going off of the scenario that we had to choose one, it will either be the 5th or 9th. 3rd squad looks down on battle and death, they think of sorrow when thinking of battle. Ichigo loves a good fight and thus does not fit with the third squad. If Ichigo were to take 5th or 9th, it is possible that Renji would take the other.