Forum:"Path of least bloodshed"

I think that I've known this for a while but it's only recently that I read the Do U Think Gin Could Turn On Aizen that I decided to put this down, Tosen meant every word of Justice and path of least bloodshed, has anyone asked themselves what would happen if Aizen won.... The guy is a megalomaniac he loves power and control therefore anyone his control would be forced to bend to his will since he has the power to do so swiftly and decisively, he won't beat around the bush and Tosen knows this all too well, (his main drive was the death of his friend right but Soul Society didn't do anything about it most likely since nothing has been said about it aside from what we got from Tosen) and thus less deaths will occur and there will be "Justice" since in Tosen's mind you sacrifice a few to save many he is, contrary to popular belief not in the very least a hypocrite.--SalmanH 19:13, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

That's under the assumption that Tosen knows what on Aizen's mind, the fact is its not likely he seems to be manipulated by Aizen, who uses his own philosophy against him. Prime example if you recall the interaction between Tosen, Aizen and Grimmjaw. After the incident Gin remarks how how he likes to mess with his subordinates. There is no doubt through the interactions that are taking place, Gin is more of an equal in terms of status with aizen or rather favor. Tosen on the other hand follows his philosophy and acts as a lowly subordinate to aizen, always asking for forgiveness and permission. I will agree in Tosen's mind he is doing the right thing, he is following his philosophy. Notice whether it be in Soul Society or Hueco Mundo he follows Aizen just the same and has a position of authority. He also as in soul society detests Kenpachi and in hueco mundo he detests Grimmjaww, neither place is any different to him, he truly is blind. Only believing in his philosophy and the notion that some way Aizen can bring it about. So i dont think there was ever a question of whether he thinks he is following his path but there is a big argument to which way one can go about it to achieve it. He chose the way that in most others minds would be the path of most bloodshed, be it shinigami or humans. As it would stand the only way that for a outsider looking in to justify his actions would require that there is actual more bloodshed by Shinigami taking place before the entire Aizen incident which is questionable. Also your right what happened to his friend deeply effected him but, least we forget we don't know the circumstances behind her death or anything besides what he is given. He is the hypocrite in the sense to how others precise him (which is normally how people classify hypercritical actions) maybe not in his mind but that doesn't make him any less of one.Salubri 19:42, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

If I may clarify a few things:
 * Shinigami and hollows have been fighting each other for what seems like an eternity, Aizen ruling over SS and Hueco Mundo without any opposition means either genocide or no feuds at all (speculation I know).


 * I agree that Tosen is perceived by others a hypocrite though it's only been mentioned by us (real people) no one in the bleach universe however, although they are probably thinking it.


 * Tosen's a slightly bigger threat to Aizen than people give him credit for, he can't be affected by his zanpakuto has a bankai that deprives you of all your senses except for touch and has pretty damn good skills in all forms of shinigami combat granted not on par with aizen but his zanpakuto's ability does give him an edge, the whole forgiveness and permission thing probably just means that he's polite or a doormat.


 * Wasn't it already mentioned that his friend was killed by her drunk husband whom she was reprimanding for killing a friend over an argument other than that... yeah I got nothing.

(PS. I really don't like him and see him as a coward but someone needs to tell his side of the story too I suppose.)--SalmanH 20:13, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

Regarding your second point, SalmanH, one of the Captains (Sajin Komamura) has questioned his philosophy, and questioned where his sense of justice is, essentially calling him a hypocrite for following Aizen, without using those precise words. Twocents 20:18, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

Oh yeah I forgot about that, thanks Twocents, do you want in on this whole thing too, we kinda need a second opinion.--SalmanH 20:28, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

The problem is hollows aren't good in any sense they feed on human souls there is no debating that, Aizen being in control wont stop their nature nor does it make sense to insinuate that being that he doesn't even control all Arrancar. This not a simple war against different ideologies. This is a situation of balance in the universe the Shinigami keep it and the hollow disrupt it. Aizen like you said wants power what he will do with that power is left up to be determined. As we see he doesn't seem to be the least concerned with what damage his arrancar do, they barely get punished if at all. As for Tosen being polite or a doormat is one thing but that is not whats being shown he acts like a servant more then anything and aizen excepts it, there is a level of respect you give others we have seen it in bleach between subordinates and captains but Tosen reaches a bit more then that. While its possible to be a danger to Aizen if Kenpachi can take his bankai without knowing what it does initially its fair to say aizen can take it though your correct his Aizen's zanpakuto cant affect him. Interestingly enough the one person who cant be effected by him is on his side. Yes it was mentioned about her death but by him we dont know what took place or what happened afterwords he like this situation we are discussing could have a completely skewed view of what transpired against someone he deeply cared for, its left in the air that's all im saying. Your also right we mention him being a hypocrite but they never say it outright though in other words komamura has brought it up on various occasions without going that far like twocents said. I really dont like him either he is a coward to me and one of my least favorite characters.Salubri 20:29, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

If you'd like SalmanH, I'll attempt to address a few of the points brought up, from my perspective.
 * I concur that, in his own mind, he has not done anything to go against his own philosophy, which does seem to suggest he's a bit more aware of what's going on than what information we readers have been given anyway. However, that doesn't prevent other people from thinking he's a hypocrite (like Sajin) or a coward (as I recall Kenpachi calling him one of the few people to fear death). It's also likely that his past experiences have had an effect on his current thoughts and actions, as you would expect with most people.


 * However, I disagree that because he cannot be affected by Aizen's Zanpakuto that he is not being manipulated. I think there are a variety of ways to trick, manipulate and control people, and while affecting what one sees is a powerful thing, so is psychologically affecting someone, which Aizen also seems to be a master at. On a side note, I would think that Gin is more resistant to that form of manipulation, seeing as he is exceptionally crafty at also using it.


 * As far as interactions with the Arrancar and Hollows, we really don't see enough of that side of it for me to formulate an opinion. Twocents 20:37, 2 August 2009 (UTC)

For the record I never really liked SalmanH it takes too long to type you could just call me hassan or hs I don't really mind, whatever you guys are comfortable with, but back to Tosen we've established that he is a coward but is following his own code his way and it doesn't matter to him what anyone else thinks about it, but I also think that because he can't be affected by Aizen's zanpakuto he became one of Aizen's right hand men in the first place and this probably done so through fear of death. So is this resolved or should we just move on to something else. In either case thanks for relaying some of your thoughts here.

We all know from TBTP that Aizen will happily frame others for his crimes. Given his penchant for planning and doing whatever it takes to advance his plans, could it be possible that Aizen killed Tosen's friend himself and blamed someone else using KS, just to set this whole thing up to get Tosen on his side? By doing that, Aizen can psychologically bribe him with this justice shpeil into following his orders (and maybe a sense of 'you still owe me'). Tosen possesses such a one-track-mind that he can't pereive any other path, and follow it blindly (bad pun, sorry) TomServo101 13:23, 3 August 2009 (UTC)

I'm not exactly comfortable with that, and it'd be pretty far back to plan that, it doesn't make a lot of sense, sorry.--SalmanH 14:19, 3 August 2009 (UTC)

'''I know no one really wants to hear too many opinions on this, but it seems to me that Tosen just hates the Soul Society. He knew this whole time from the beginning he would fight and likely kill his fellow shinigami Komamura and Hisagi and he had no prblem with that. This might mean he has no problem walking the path of his enemies' blood, but not the blood of his comrades. He might hate Soul Society, especially the gotei 13, because of what happened to his friend. No one tried to stop the woman's drunk husband and we don't even know if he was punished for it. So it might all just be revenge and the desire to have someone else takeover whom he believes will remodel the system to fit Tosen's ideals. Aizen seems to be the one who Tosen believes will do this so even if Aizen is manipulating him, he doesn't really care. He would rather pledge loyalty to dangerous and manipulative madman than Soul Society. Another tid bit, if you guys don't mind. Aizen may be a master manipulator, but why is it that he shows favoritism towards Tosen and Ichimaru over the Arrancar? Its possible becuse he can replace any of the Arrancar with newer and stronger ones, but would lose valuable assets in his fellow former captains. I am not saying he isn't manipulating them, but their association is leaning towards loyalty more than manipulation. Just a few theories, please don't burn me at the stake. :)--Moe1216 17:02, 3 August 2009 (UTC)'''

'''Yes but unfortunately with Aizen nothing makes sense the very idea he can manipulate and plan everything is not probable. He would have to be able to see the future and personally know the inner workings of everyones mind to do what he does regardless of how good he is. The who explanation he gave at the soul society arc behind what he did and planned was way to far fetched to be believable the knowing about fake karakura town and that soul society would send the captains to hueco mundo also not believable if we are going from that manipulating tosen the way twoservo101 says is not improbable at all. It probably makes the most sense if you think of it, Gin was already along a path of destruction when he met him but what of tosen whats the liklyhood this woman got killed by her husband drunk husband for yelling at him for killing a friend. When in soul Society as wild as it is do you recall this happening. Unless they were in the bad section but are we to believe a trained shinigami couldnt defend herself. Also ive firmly believed for a long time Aizen has been using the arrancar, if you notice he doesn't seem to care if they live or die or what they do as long its in the parameters of him being in control.Salubri 17:11, 3 August 2009 (UTC)'''

'''First off Moe you have every right to voice your opinion on this article that's one of the reasons why I started this article and second there's the whole Turn back the pendulum arc, Aizen has been planning for every possible (least or very) outcome, every twist and turn every backdoor in case there was any sort of flaw in his plans from probably in his early Shinigami days I'm talking from right out of the academy once he learned about the King's key and it's no big secret, and yes I am very aware that this is all Speculation i am really getting tired of hearing that (no hostility intended). Oh yeah I put this text and the two on top in bold cause frankly the screen's bright and the text is thin.--SalmanH 18:53, 3 August 2009 (UTC)'''

Thank you very much SalmanH. See, what I noticed about Aizen was that its not only his ability to manipulate that is dangerous; it's his charisma. He naturally draws people to him because of who he is, and it helps in his tactics. Iceringer himself said that the reason the Arrancar follow him was because he had no fear, something they found inspiring. Maybe that's what brought Tosen into his leagues. He made Tosen see that he was some kind of savior or something, and with Tosen on his side, he managed not only to turn eight shinigami into vizards, but he also helped him retrieve the hogyoku, and gain an ally who would be the only person immune to kyoka suigetsu. My point in all this is that its not only his manipulation that helped him create in army, but his ability to draw people close to himself using his charismatic nature.--Moe1216 21:14, 3 August 2009 (UTC)

I wonder if Tosen is as blind in his loyalty to Aizen as everyone supposes. Tosen is very black & white in his morality. He is also a Utopianist of the worst sort...the kind that can't accept the universe the way it is and will destroy it to make it 'better'. Tosen also knows that Aizen has the potential to actually bring the massive kinds of changes he desires.

With all of the above factored in Tosen could very well calculate that the risk he takes allying with Aizen is worth the prize (Tosen's 'better world'). When all is said and done what Aizen wants is very simple...ultimate power and control. That kind of control brings with it a sort of order that could be acceptable to Tosen if it stops the sins he rails against. What happens in-between...however many bodies Tosen has to walk over...is irrelevant as long as the goal is achieved.

So the first poster isn't wrong...in this light Tosen isn't being hypocritical. He is being perversely logical, consistent, & aware in everything he does and sacrifices. Aizen may be manipulating Tosen but he does it with Tosen's full consent and knowledge.

Just my two cents.

Great Cthulhu 22:39, 3 August 2009 (UTC)
 * I actually think that's a really interesting theory. And a very plausible one, as well. Twocents 23:44, 3 August 2009 (UTC)

Great Cthulu, THAT WAS AWESOME.--Moe1216 01:36, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Yes Great Cthulhu, very good. Your point of view can be used to explain Tousen's behaviour so far. People just have to deal with Aizen almighty strategy skills. It's unrealistic? Yes. Does it matter? Not really, it keeps the anime flowing and full of action. Deimonos 02:32, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Yes Great Cthulhu you do make a good points into Tosen's mind set, yet just to point out I don't think anyone questions that in his mind he is following his path. But knowing that doesn't take away from how is perceived either by us or those in the storyline, his actions are highly hypocritical in relation to whatever he may believe as from the perception of others. he cant stop being hypocritical just because he justifies his view. Also aizen's being unrealistic does matter hence why it was brought up, it doesnt make the story full of action or flow thats not true there are plenty of things that take place outside of Aizen's so called plans or things not accounted for, so it actually serves no purpose and is more of a deterrence to his character.Salubri 03:10, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Oh well, and here I was thinking that the matter at hand was Tousen's odd choice of walking by Aizen's side after all that lecture about Kenpachi being all about endless fighting and the whole unecessary killing going on. As for everything else, Kubo writes the stories. Some may think the current events are too far fetched but that's how it is. "Oh but there're a lot things that could've been brought up for more plot stories and this and that".. ok, sure but at the moment, it is what it is.. so unless you're planning on writing another Bleach manga by yourself, there ain't no use in writing on every single thread about his unrealistic planning of events and everything else you think should happen. There's a thin line between expressing one's opinion and just bitching about storylines you don't like.. Deimonos 03:23, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Yea i do believe in what Great Cthulhu and Salubri said works on both sides. Great Cthulhu made a point on what Tosen maybe felling or believing and Salubri made a point on the outside perceptions which lead others to question his actions as hypocritical. Also on the side bar I do find the whole Aizen manipulation thing to be a bit outside of probability its just way to much wheres the character flaw that a villain normally has maybe its his arrogance and overconfidence that seems to be the biggest issue with the antagonists in the series. In any case I do believe he is using the manipulation aspect regardless of if tosen knows or not but if one was to try to give tosen the benefit of the doubt they would say he isnt aware of being used. Its one of those things we will have to see. In this upcoming fight we see Tosen and his self righteousness spouting off his philosophy on fighting to hisagi as if he knows so much, I personally get the feeling he is about to be schooled himself. lol.Innocent Anna 03:29, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Well you would know all about it Deimonos seeing as you seem to have to always express your opinion in disagreement of mine instead of minding your own business. Instead of bitching about me saying my opinion as im not here for you to address anything i say. ill administer whatever opinion i see fit. Your the one making up unrealistic scenarios all over place and now your using the same statement i said to you previously about making up stuff so far fetched your boarding on writing your own story. I can complain if i so choice hopefully without you having to comment on everything i say.Salubri 03:36, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

I'm confused as to how Salubri's very valid point could be constituted, as you so colorfully put it, as "bitching about storylines you don't like." I think it's relevant in the sense that while we, as readers, are not in a position to understand, for example, how Aizen knew that Yamamoto would send half of the Gotei 13 to Hueco Mundo and developed a plan around it, it points out that the characters, especially Aizen, are aware and capable of controlling and manipulating situations and characters in a way that we can't see or understand, currently. Which relates to pondering precisely how or if Tosen is being manipulated, as since Aizen is capable of manipulating situations so far in advance so as it be improbable in what little of the situation we can see, it makes sense then that he is capable of manipulating people who should be immune to his abilities, even if it seems improbably to us and we can't see precisely how he's doing it. Twocents 03:38, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Hmm, indeed. Anime cliches tell me Aizen would have to bashed by the main character but I don't see it. Shinji has to be the one doing it. Now about Tousen, I think Great Chtulhu's idea made a lot of sense to me but then again, anything can happen. Next chapters will show us his insight. People are even thinking Hisagi will show some unrevealed bankai.. lol Deimonos 03:38, 4 August 2009 (UTC)

Salubri. Yeah....I don't deny that my closing point about Tosen's hypocrisy was a bit weak. The truth is Tosen IS a hypocrite even if it was just because he hid the true extremity of his beliefs to appear more moderate to his fellow shinigami. Great Cthulhu 04:32, 4 August 2009 (UTC)