Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6299840-20140802043614/@comment-28861328-20140802235445

Xilinoc wrote: Ten Tailed Fox wrote: Yumichika.

The smell of semen.

His (yes his) admission to getting off at killing Bambietta (which explains the smell).

The fact that Bambietta all but outright begged to give him a blowjob (I'm not even going to attempt to censor that).

Now Charolotte.

But you're right. Way too vague. >_> Let's face it, at this point, the only thing "more definitive" would be "him" whipping it out, because that is the only real proof there can ever be... besides the obviousness of Kubo throwing it at us. Charlotte is an entire new character, unaware of Yumichika's "taunting", and makes the same accusation, so I don't see how this is even debatable any more. Well, there's always the possibility that Giselle's a hermaphrodite, or a man who wishes to identify as a woman, or whatnot. That makes it not exactly definitive in terms of a conclusion.

Hermaphrodite is a possibility, but Charlotte clearly said "you're like me". What is Charlotte? A man who dresses like a woman. That's not a hermaphrodite. Secondly, I don't buy into political correctness. Identifying as a female while still genetically a male (which the smell of semen after getting off confirms) sill makes one a male. If it absolutely has to be address, do what we do with Charlotte. Mention it in the personality and appearance sections.

He is male, though. Kubo has given us everything but a nude shot to prove it.