Forum:Isshin Kurosaki Royal Guard or 11th Division ? (Thread closed)

I heard this from several people as a rumor, but I think it deserves discussion anyway. I heard that Isshin may have been a former royal guard, which, besides Yamamoto, only the most powerful shinigami may be a part of. Do any of you think its possable?--CloudHiro 05:33, 19 April 2009 (UTC)

Has anyone ever had the theory that maybe he was the former Captain of the 11th squad? This would explain why the 11th squad captain was never shown in Turn Back the Pendulum series. Yes Shinji said he didn't recognize the spirit energy but maybe that's because he had lost most of it. This could also fall into line that Kenpachi Zaraki killed Isshin to become the new captain. But Isshin never dies and is brought to the real world. Hence Isshin losing his powers. This would explain why he knows Urahara because they were both captains at the same time. This would also explain why most of the older captains go out of their way to help Ichigo. Like Ukitake and Kyōraku. Even Kenpachi himself.

Also notice the similarity in Kenpachis haori with Isshins. They are both frayed at the bottom.

I think he was Captain of the 10th before Hitsugaya. Hitsugaya couldn't be a captain for a long time cause he's a child, However, he might be captain of the 11th as well, because Kenpachi is no murderer and has always shown mercy with his oppononents and has only killed them when they don't accept that it is over like nnoitra. However, he still has his haori and thats the point. Kenpachi has taken his haori from the previous captain so if isshin was from the 11th he wouldn't have his haori.--Suzumushi 10:02, 19 April 2009 (UTC)

its actualy well established that Kenpatchi killed the previous 11th captain, because it is stated that there are only 2 ways a shinigami can become a part ofthe gotei 13, ether by acheveing bankai, or by killing the previous captain with a certain amount of shinigami present. Also, though it may be a filler arc, it is pretty much blatently said that Kempatchi killed the previous captain, and even though its a filler arc, it still carries some weight on the series. If Isshin was the 11'th squad captain, he was most likely removed from this position and replaced by the captain that was killed by Kenpatchi. but then again, its more likely that he was the captain of the 10th squad, and perhaps a kings guard after that, since he only gave up/lost his shinigami powers 20 years prior to the start of the series, which is consistant to when Hitsugaya became captain --CloudHiro 11:13, 19 April 2009 (UTC)

Yes the 10th Division argument tends to carry more weight. The 11th Division is stated more then once in the series to have had the previous Captain before Zaraki killed by him. While yes the flash back is only seen in the bount arc it is pretty much confirmed in Turn back the pendulum arc in conversation. As for isshin he was only gone from soul society for the past 20 yrs, which plays toward the 10 division position. Salubri 12:22, 19 April 2009 (UTC)

speaking of which, if he was the former 10th devision captain, what do you think will happen now since it apears that Hitsugaya is being beaten, above a fake version of what and where used to be Karakura Town? I doupt he would have been put to sleep as well and Im shure he is aware of the situation. do you think he'll come to the captain's aid? this is just idle speculation on my part. pay no mind to it. --CloudHiro 20:45, 19 April 2009 (UTC)

Nah i dont think he'll get involved he obviously left for a reason and to be honest we really dont know whats gonna happen with hitsuguya, though its interesting to see that Halibel may or may not have some type of original form after her release that deals with water, really how well is that gonna go with someone who has power over ice. we'll just have to see. Salubri 00:04, 20 April 2009 (UTC)

--CloudHiro 03:36, 24 April 2009 (UTC)


 * The Eleventh Division is discarded when we consider that Kenpachi carried the previous captain's haori with him, while Isshin still has his. The Seaweed Ambassador 00:45, 12 June 2009 (UTC)

The point of him being the former 11th division captain is not even logical at this point as we know for a fact the one previous to Zaraki was killed by him in a duel and Zaraki has been captain for over 110 yrs. Now its been said that Isshin hasn't been a Shinigami in 20 yrs. If he was a captain then he would have been in the last 20 yrs the most recent captain is more then likely Hitsugaya so he was probably former 10 th division captain, and then i would go on to say that considering his medical background he may have been a seated member of the 4th division at some point.Salubri 01:41, 12 June 2009 (UTC)

Zaraki has not been a captain for over 110 years. He became Captain while Tosen was a Captian, and in the TBTP arc Tosen was still a seated officer or below and that was 100 years prior to the main story. I am still sticking with that he was the Kenpachi before Zaraki. Maybe Azien used Kyōka Suigetsu to make it look like Zaraki killed Isshin. Then Isshin was forced into exile since he was thought to be dead. I'm sticking with this theory. My second option would be that Isshin is Yoruichi Shihōin brother that took over the second squad after Yoruichi was exiled. Don't forget Soifon stated the Yoruichi had a brother who was a disgrace to the family. The theory of Isshin being the Captain of the 10th before Hitsugaya IMO is the last one I would pick. There isn't a reason for it. No back story. At least my other 2 theory's have a back story or reasoning to it. Quadrupus 02:05, 12 June 2009 (UTC)

Shows how much you have actually read or maybe havent read but watched. zaraki became a captain before urahara did 110 years ago that much was stated by shinji. maybe you should actually read turn back the pendulum before you start making assumptions. Tosen didnt become captain until sometime later off panel (bount arc anime is a filler and anime is secondary sourcing not to mention that it came out before they did the turn back the pendulum came out and manga is first sourcing therefore it takes precedence of anime). Not to mention your ridiculous speculation is entirely out of place and makes no sense seeing as isshin in conversation with urahara talks about fighting aizen. secondly Soifon was talking about her brothers who died on their missions for the stealth force, something else you should actually read. Salubri 02:28, 12 June 2009 (UTC)


 * Well on all this it is still unknown when Isshin was, if he indeed was a Captain (no one has blatanly said that he was, and our only clue is that he has a haori), he would either have been a Captain before Shinji joined or after Shinji left due to him not recognizing the energy. As we know even when someone has increased or decreased their power others still recognize the specific signature of the Reiatsu. Another thing is Shinji said that the Captain of the 11th Division was named Kenpachi just like is tradition with all the 11th Division Captains, he never says that this Kenpachi is indeed Zaraki just a Kenpachi so until we know that they are both the same the info from the Bount arc (in which Tosen) is the most conclusive info we have. As far as the royal guard that is also a posibility for Isshin as we know only former Captains are members. So all in all we don't know anything about his past so we should refrain from adding any of this info in any of wiki's articles. WhiteStrike 04:23, 12 June 2009 (UTC)

See heres the biggest problem with assuming the 11th division. Shinji and loves conversation goes like this. Shinji says the 11th sqaud isnt here. love responds "he is slacking off, looks like he isnt listening to what he's told, as usual". To which shinji says "10th generation kenpachi or not he's a pain in the ass, why would they make such a guy a captain. Love says  it cant be helped, every generation of the squad 11 captain has been a kenpach thats the custom. Shinji then responds If anyone's to blame, its the former kenpachi for losing to this guy". True enough his name wasn't said but everyones willing to believe from some pics in the manga that tosen's zanpakuto belonged to his friend originally but not that zaraki was the kenpachi in question. Now lets think about this, how many kenpachi's do we know slacks off when it comes to formalities and rarely does what he's told. Also how many kenpachi's do we know having killed the previous one. last i can recall we know of only one, zaraki. Also considering tosen cant stand zaraki for this reason, how many people have used that third method to become captain only one that we know of. Anything else is speculation we know all this much about zaraki and yet virtually nothing about isshins role in soul society. even if we went with the bount filler he still would have been the guy who killed the previous captain all that would have changed is the date which is still around 100 yrs. Also everyone including tosen said the guy was dead. Salubri 05:03, 12 June 2009 (UTC)

Just read through the posts and i saw CloudHiro say that there are two ways to become a captain and that one of them was to acheive bankai. Just want to point out how wrong he is actually, there are three ways:

1) Captain proficiency test (隊首, taishu): A test which requires the ability to perform Bankai. Presumably, most shinigami become captains using this method. At least three existing captains, including the Commander-General, have to witness the test.

2) Personal Recommendation: To have personal recommendations from at least six captains and approval from at least three of the remaining seven.

3) Trial by Combat: To defeat a captain one-on-one with at least 200 witnesses from the captain's division. Kenpachi Zaraki is the only known current captain to have achieved his rank using this method. This method is seen as being the exceedingly rarer of the three as well as the least refined. The method is commonly looked down upon by some captains as barbaric compared to the other refined methods. This method also allows one to bypass having the mastery of bankai or other possible abilities that a captain would otherwise be required to have knowledge of, as it allows no judgement from captains who would require those skills as a prerequisite to join their ranks.

Just wanted to point that out. Sanbuntaicho 12:35, 12 June 2009 (UTC)