Talk:Retsu Unohana

Inaccuracy in Soul Society Arc Info
In the article, it states that Captain Unohana first reveals her healing skills when she heals Renji after he is injured by Byakuya; however, this only occurs in the anime. In the manga, it is Hanatarou upon the request of Rikichi who performs the healing. For a reference, you even cite the manga pages which clearly show that Hanatarou is the one doing the healing. In the manga, Unohana and Isane are perfectly on-time at the execution site with Yamamoto and the others.

Since Unohana performing the healing only occurs in the anime and not in the manga, should this not be changed to reflect the more accurate portrayal of Unohana? Yumechou (talk) 09:07, January 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * I'm not exactly sure what you are referring to when you say "you event cite". This is a freely editable encyclopaedia open to anyone so saying such could sound a bit too much like taking issue with someone specific. If you could please think a bit more carefully about the wording of what you write in case some people might take it the wrong way. But you raise a valid point, as per the anime policy, the anime contradicts the manga on this so the manga version should be used. And the way it is written is not up to spec either. This looks to be something that has been there since long before the site's current strict rules and standards were enforced. Not every little bit like that has been found yet, but most of it has been cleaned up by now. Thanks for pointing it out and I've removed it. 13:27, January 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * I'm sorry about the tone of my writing if it sounded accusatory as that was not my intention. When I said "you even cite" there, it is because the reference used for that instance actually showed the Hanatarou and Rikichi doing the task unlike what was written. Thank you for making the correction. Yumechou (talk) 19:36, January 22, 2012 (UTC)


 * No worries. "The article says" or something to that effect might work better. 19:56, January 22, 2012 (UTC)