User talk:Wazawhy

Re: Ise Nanao
It's the most common-sense deduction to make from those chapters. Why would Nanao's mom have gone to Shunsui to protect her if her brother weren't Nanao's paternal father, thus giving Shunsui a familial reason to do so? Moreover, why would she marry a second man after the "Ise curse" killed her first husband, and why would we spend so much time learning about them as a couple if another man were the real father who came into the picture later? We have to account for conservation of detail when making inferences from the manga, rather than simply assume could-bes and maybes for any old reason. Finally, there's nothing to indicate that Shunsui would have to look as old as Nanao does if she were conceived while he was a child, given how variably Souls age and mature in the series. As it stands, much like our inference (later proven canon by the anime) that Isshin was the uncle mentioned by Kūkaku and Ganju early in TYBW, there's nothing indicating that Shunsui isn't Nanao's biological uncle, and I'm pretty sure Kubo would've made it clear in those flashbacks or the present day if he intended for them to have some other connection instead.--Xilinoc (talk) 07:15, 10 May 2023 (UTC)